Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Why should you have to travel outside of your community to get quality diamonds, fine jewelry, and the courteous attention you deserve? This is the question that prompted Kaz Bagheri to form Bentley Diamond Importers in 1989. Since then Bentley Diamond Importers and Fine Jewelry has established itself as the premiere diamond headquarters in the tri-state area, and has earned a reputation for the highest standards and consistently low prices in the industry.Bentley Diamond Importers offers a premier selection of styles in New Jersey.
Follow us
Services
Why should you have to travel outside of your community to get quality diamonds, fine jewelry, and the courteous attention you deserve? This is the question that prompted Kaz Bagheri to form Bentley Diamond Importers in 1989 on the Jersey Shore. Since then Bentley Diamond Importers and Fine Jewelry has established itself as a premier diamond headquarters in the tri-state area, and has earned a reputation for the highest standards and low prices in the industry.As direct importers, Bentley Diamond knows the history of each carefully selected diamond.
Each reflects the story of its arduous journey from deep inside the earth to a cherished object of adornment. Yet all diamonds share certain features that allow us to compare and evaluate them. These features of a diamond are called the 4C's and represent Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat weight. A certificate from the world's most respected laboratories accompanies all fine quality diamonds from Bentley. The report will fully describe the stone and evaluate each of the diamond's critical factors affecting it's quality, beauty, and value.
The classic beauty of a diamond engagement ring has touched the hearts of generations of young lovers and is a specialty of Bentley Diamond & Fine Jewelry. We know diamonds, and we want you to benefit from our many years of experience. Browse our amazing selection of halo, three stone, side stone, and solitaire engagement rings.
Bentley Diamond maintains diverse collections of beautiful Estate Jewelry. Our inventory of Estate pieces is constantly being updated as items are bought and sold, so come into the store and browse for the perfect piece! We carry all types of Estate Jewelry from diamonds rings, gold jewelry, necklaces, bracelets, earrings, engagement rings and wedding bands to just about anything you can think of! We are constantly updating our Estate Jewelry inventory and you'll only see a small fraction of our jewelry online.
Reviews (28)
Write a Review
Rick Barroquero
May 14, 2022
Bentley Diamond is a wonderful place to purchase jewelry. We have been dealing with Nancy for a few years now. She never disappoints. So knowledgeable and she has years of experience.
Joseph Pollara
Jan 16, 2022
I made an appointment to see Rick Abreu to look for an engagement ring. I was greeted promptly and cheerfully by the staff and Rick brought me into his office. He took his time explaining diamonds to me before he even began to show me any. He walked me carefully through the selection process never rushing nor pressuring me. I am beyond satisfied and recommend that you visit Rick at Bentley Diamond.
James DeMarco
Jan 07, 2022
Rick was wonderful in helping reset my wife's engagement ring. He was very knowledgeable and assisted in every stage of the remount. The ring is so beautiful. I would highly recommend Bently Diamond for every aspect of your jewelry needs. Thank you Rick!
Jeremy Link
Dec 23, 2021
Had an amazing experience with Nancy at Bentley Diamond. I went in looking for an engagement ring and she far exceeded my expectations. Nancy was extremely helpful and very personable. She took the time to get to know me first even before we started looking at any rings. This meant a lot because it showed she actually cares about her customers and is not only interested in making a sale.

On top of that, she was extremely knowledgeable and very professional. All said and done, she helped me find exactly what I was looking for and I couldn't be more pleased. If you're looking for an engagement ring, I would highly recommend Nancy at Bentley Diamond.
Mark S.
Dec 05, 2021
I really love this store, and I am a repeat customer. Our salesperson, Rick A., was so incredibly helpful and knowledgeable. I completely trust that I am getting a great product. I don't need to go any wear else for diamond jewelry. Thanks Bentley. Mark S.
Kelly
Nov 17, 2021
I had the BEST experience at Bentley Diamond. I called to inquire about possibly changing the setting on my engagement ring. I made an appointment with Rick, who was able to accommodate a same day appointment. With the help of Rick (and assistance from Melinda), I purchased a new setting that I am in love with. Rick's knowledge and honesty helped me to make a clear, confident decision in purchasing a new band that was perfect for me.

I was able to get it sized and my diamond set all in the same day. Dave (I think that was his name?) set my ring and was amazing as well. I walked in just "to look" and ended up with the ring I always envisioned. It's the customer service that makes the difference- I genuinely trust this business and will be returning again. Thank you thank you!
Stephanie Brengel
May 20, 2021
My husband purchased my engagement ring and wedding band here along with an anniversary band. I had a very specific idea in mind for my engagement ring, and they found the PERFECT setting to match what I envisioned. I constantly get compliments on my ring set. The staff is always so friendly, kind, knowledgeable, helpful, and easy to talk to. It's obvious they love what they do and want to help the customer find exactly what they're looking for. Bentley has an incredible selection- I just love going in there and could easily spend all day there trying on jewelry and chatting with the staff.

We've been back to have my rings cleaned multiple times and resized once as well, which they did flawlessly. Thank you, Bentley Diamond, for the most delightful shopping experience to help make our engagement absolutely perfect from the very moment we began looking for my ring!
John C.
Feb 11, 2021
Ordered a wedding band. It came in a a couple of days before the wedding. They must of ordered the wrong size because the band did not even come close to fitting me. They gave me the band they in the counter that fit me. At the time I did not know this, the band was engraved sample. So I probably paid for a fake sample. Either way I have a band that says sample that I'm stuck with that I paid way too much for.
Jakarta Williams
Feb 07, 2021
While searching for an engagement ring for my girlfriend, I had several jewelry stores on my list. Bentley Diamond was referred by a friend and naturally became my first stop. Everyone at the jewelry store was very friendly and helpful. As soon as I walked in I was greeted by kind staff and offered assistance right away. Rick assisted me with finding the perfect engagement ring for my girlfriend, soon to be fiance. Rick patiently helped me find a ring and he was AMAZING!

Without much knowledge walking in, I gained so much information walking out. Rick was such a breath of fresh air during what would be a stressful process for any man. Rick made my entire experience a delight. Rick has so much knowledge of Diamonds and was happy to share his knowledge. Rick was a pleasure to work with. He is professional, has great humor, and patience which made this experience fun, relaxing and informative. If you're in search of an engagement ring or any other jewelry, Rick is the guy that I recommend seeing for an unforgettable shopping experience.
Amy Toman
Feb 06, 2021
I visited Bentley hoping to find a diamond band for my wedding anniversary. I was overwhelmed by the wide selection of beautiful jewelry and the patient and knowledgeable assistance of the staff. Melinda showed me rings and bands and really honed in on my style. She took a good deal time with me as I chose the perfect ring. I also ended up getting a new pair of diamond earrings and was able to re-rhodium a couple of rings. I love Bentley and will be recommending them to others.
Wayne I.
Feb 02, 2021
I met with Rick Abreu of Bentley Diamond to pick out a very special piece of jewelry. Rick was professional and listened to my preferences. He did not push me in any direction but guided me with his vast knowledge and superior expertise. Overall, a wonderful experience with Rick and his team at Bentley. I highly recommend them!
Denise Y.
Dec 24, 2020
Was in there yesterday to get an estimate on some jewelry I wanted to sell. Was made to feel like they didn't want to be bothered with doing that, days before Christmas. As the half-interested man reviewed my pieces, he offered me $880 for a single Diamond earring I had. I returned to Earth Treasures, where I've bought and sold jewelry over 25 years. They gave me $2250 for that same single earring! Buyers beware! The store in Eatontown is your best bet!
Amy McGowan
Oct 31, 2020
There aren't enough words to express how wonderful of an experience we had with Bentley Diamond. We started ring browsing in early March before Covid which came to a standstill. After a few long months we were able to shop again and had a better idea of the style of the ring we wanted to purchase. Daria listened and took all of our wishes into account and came up with the most perfectly designed ring.

My fiance and I instantly connected with her. She made us feel so comfortable and there was no pressure. We even had a private appointment one day & I felt like Reese Witherspoon in the jewelry store w/ Patrick Dempsey in Sweet Home Alabama. She took her time with us and taught us a lot about the different diamonds and important things about them.

She knew something I really wanted was to incorporate rose gold into the setting which was also done. She spent countless hours with us and made it truly a wonderful experience especially in such a crazy time in the world. Each time we walked into the store, the staff and whole team were kind & friendly. Daria even found us a diamond with special sentiments within its measurements & made it more unique to us as a couple.

I cannot say enough about our overall experience, the professionalism and quality of service Bentley & Daria provided to us. Also, I have a spectacular ring I get to stare at forever!
Kathy C.
Aug 01, 2020
I just discovered Bentleys They are just great to work with. My pug got ahold of my gold claddagh ring, I thought it was a goner. (400.00) The jeweler looked at it, and said he could work with it. OMGOSH, he did a beautiful job. AND very reasonable also. I had Nancy give me an appraisal on another ring. She also is just great to work with. Jared's wanted 150.00 for the appraisal, Nancy charged me 75.00.

What great people. I looked at some very beautiful estate jewelry also. I found a great price on a ring. I put it on like a lay-a-way. I have really been happy with Bentleys, and for sure I'll buy other pieces from them. (By the way, they also cleaned many rings for me at no extra charge.) Great place to shop. Kathleen Cronick
Kathy S.
Dec 13, 2019
My daughter and I were in Florida. We went shopping one day in Saks and my daughter saw a ring she loved. It was a size too large but we were told we could get it sized so we bought it. When we got home, we went to Bentley and was greeted by Joanna. We told her what we needed to do and she gave us the bad news. The ring had very tiny diamonds and to bring it down to the size we needed, the little diamonds would most likely fall out so it couldn't be done.

We were very disappointed but we understood what the problem was and we were sorry that the sales lady at Saks didn't know this would be a problem. I returned the ring to Saks and started looking online for something else. And then I thought, why not go back to Bentley's and see what they could do. I dealt with Joanna again and she was thrilled to be able to try to help us, and I was thrilled that she was willing to help us!

Most places, when you give them a dollar amount, they send you away and say sorry we have nothing in your price range. Not Joanna! She said, I'm gonna work on this and I'm gonna find your daughter a ring she will love in your price range! Well, Joanna did not disappoint! She got back to us, showed us what she could do and we are beyond happy!

My daughter loves the ring Joanna found for her and with luck we will have it in time for Christmas. I was in the retail business for 25 years. I know what it takes to provide good customer service and Joanna is the Queen of good customer service! It is refreshing to come across someone like Joanna who goes out of her way to help people and we are so appreciative!

We are now lifetime customers of Bentley Jewelers! We can't promise they will get rich off of our purchases, but not only will we be lifetime customers, but I am going to tell everyone I know about the wonderful experience we had at Bentley's! Thank you Joanna and everyone at Bentley Jewelers!
Raph S.
Sep 14, 2019
As a novice in fine jewelry, I thought finding the perfect engagement ring was going to be challenge. I wanted something that she was going to cherish, be proud, and feel it as one of the many representations of my love; it's a lot of pressure for someone who doesn't know anything about engagement rings. I immediately searched online for help, looking at a few styles and hints I picked up but everything was beginning to look vey similar.

I was over saturated and feeling a little lost when I decided to physically l see the rings at Bentley Diamond. There is a big difference in seeing the rings in person and over the internet. Not only did Shirley help find the perfect diamond she also helped narrow my search down to a single ring and even ordered the white gold version of it when it wasn't in stock; it was a huge hit!

My fiancee loves it so much and we're even getting compliments from everyone! I would highly recommend Bentley Diamond to all my friends and family. Everyone there is so friendly and works with you until you find exactly what you want. Thank you Bentley Diamond, Shirley, and the entire team. We can't wait to return for our wedding bands.
Esther S.
Aug 11, 2019
Horrible company to deal with. My son bought a wedding band for $1100 that they said was on sale from $1700. 2 months later the relationship he was in ended and he asked to return the UNWORN band. Even asked if Bentley would give hime $500 for it. It was their own piece of jewelry they sold him for $1100 and they would not take it back at all, not even willing to exchange it for a credit or another piece of jewelry.

Another time I brought several pieces of jewelry to sell. I got $2500 more for selling the exact same pieces from someone else. So beware of this company. Best to do business with someone more reputable.
Joe C.
Jul 27, 2019
I can't say enough good things about the folks at Bentley's. Professional, beyond belief. Knowledgable, kind, sincere, honest. I brought a family diamond in and they provided a temporary setting for.my daughter so I could.help.her.fiance surprise her. Not only that, but they gave me.full.credit toward the actual setting, the installation of the stone and an appraisal and reappraisal for the final.product. we return s two weeks later and again they knocked out.aocks.off.qith stellar service.

They sized, remount s.and rework d.a.new.setting so.she could.leave the same.day with her new ring.thank you Bentley. Kudos to John, Nancy, Shelly and the jeweler and stone setter whkse names don't remember. I have had other work done there, ri gs, bracelets, appraisal's etc. And have always left there happy. Oh, they also have coffee and cookies. Think I'm happy?
Ann M.
Feb 05, 2019
Rude people. Stuck up. Bad trade-in values. Donot recommend. Maybe they only cater to millionaires! Lol
Jamie Z.
Oct 29, 2018
Bentley Diamond is amazing! Everyone was extremely helpful in consulting and explaining the engagement ring process to me. I was able to select a perfect ring for my fiance, and they completed a complicated sizing process a few days later. Joanna and Daria are experts on diamonds and rings. I can't recommend their service enough!
Laura D.
Sep 04, 2018
Great experience! We loved working with Joanna, Daria, David, Tony and the whole crew. I had a custom eternity band and earring jackets made out of my grandmother's diamonds. Joanna was wonderful--super knowledgeable, responsive and all around fun to work with. I'm thrilled with how the jewelry turned out and happy to now have a jeweler that we trust.
Alexis K.
Aug 04, 2018
Awful! Had a ring made here almost 8 years ago. With stones from various different jewelry. They appraised it for me. I went back today to possibly sell it back, they asked me how much I wanted for it, I didn't share the number they appraised it for, or the number I was willing to take. I was offered 30 THOUSAND DOLLARS. LESS than what THEY appraised it at. Bad shady business do not recommend.
Karyn Ippolito B.
Feb 11, 2017
Beyond disappointed! My husband purchased a bezel set diamond band ring for me for Christmas from Bentley Diamond. This was not a custom order but a ring from their case. The ring is too big and I am unable wear it. He returned to the store and asked if they could exchange the ring for the correct size and he was told they would only size the ring for him and they would not exchange the ring or take the ring back. Sizing a bezel set ring would compromise the setting of the diamonds.

They have lost our business and will make sure to spread the word to my husband's friends and co-workers that the customer service and their exchange policy is very poor. And to top it off - first they gave us an appraisal that was less than what was paid. and for a ring setting that was different than what was purchased!
Melissa A.
Jan 19, 2017
We started our ring shopping at Bentley. Over the next 2 weeks we shopped around at about 5 other stores.we went back to Bentley. Robert made us feel very comfortable. We were not pressured or harrassed as we had been at other jewelers. He spent a lot of time with us and helped make the right decision for what we wanted. Thank you for making what could be a greuling process as easy as possible!
Rick L.
Nov 15, 2015
Thanks so much for providing us with such an amazing ring for our special day! Dealing with Bentley Diamond has been an absolute pleasure. When I walked in the door the very first time, I had no intentions of buying a ring but Nancy was so pleasant and help me to find the ring I'd dreamed about. My fiance hasn't stopped telling me how perfect her engagement ring and now wedding bands are. Nancy helped so much in the selection of both.

She has flawless taste and made so many great suggestions that it was almost too hard to choose, until she showed us a piece we fell in love with. The only "problem" was that it was all white Gold and Krisytn really wanted mixed metals. NO PROBLEM! They completely customized the bands and added Rose Gold accents. It's honestly one of the most beautiful rings Ive ever seen now. Can't possibly say how grateful I am and will definitely recommend to family and friends.
Nina G.
Sep 07, 2015
My fiance bought my engagement ring at this jeweler. We were charged an extra 100 for the extra platinum they needed to make the ring a 1/2 size larger. Then we brought in my mother in laws engagement ring that has been in the family for decades. I asked them to clean it and they charged me another $100. Then asked them what they could do to make the ring smaller for me and they said nothing.

They said the ring was unwearable. I was upset about that so I took that ring to 3 other very reputable jewelers and all said it was extremely wearable and gave me about 3 ideas on how to make smaller without compromising the ring. This experience was so dissapointed to me. I have never been charged to clean a ring at a jewelry store even if I didn't buy it there. And on top to tell me completely wrong information is sad. I hope they look at their policies a bit better
Jim M.
Jan 17, 2015
I visited today to sell an old ring I won in 2002. David was very nice and personable. I feel like he gave me a good deal and would go back in the future if I had more gold to sell.
Georgina G.
Oct 18, 2012
Just for entertainment value, I called Bentley when we were ready to buy our wedding rings. I could get the matching one for my engagement ring and my fiance would get the cobalt ring we liked there. I had already been to another jeweler in Toms River earlier in the day and got a quote from them on my matching Amavida band. I told the jewelry store in Toms River that I was going to comparison shop to the place where we bought my engagement ring.

I called Bentley, the usual woman answered the phone and I let her know that I wanted to speak with [saleswoman's name I can't remember; wasn't even going to give Robert a try as that just seems hopeless]. I told her that I bought my engagement ring there, we were ready to purchase wedding bands and I wanted to speak to the saleswoman about order turnaround and cost.

I was asked my name, my fiance's name, my phone number (repeated back to me) and I have never received a call back. Must be nice to turn away business! We went with the jewelry store in Toms River and from beginning to end, across 3 visits, they were nothing short of a class act.