Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Blue Diamond Jewelers Uniquely designed, one of a kind pieces created by artists with the utmost quality in genuine materials. Have a look at some of our works of art, you are in good hands working with a family owned business in the industry for four generations! We have had the same trustworthy jeweler working on our client's items since our inception in Estero. Broken chains, replacing stones, you name it, we do it!

We only sell new pieces and stones that are GIA certified. We don't ever sacrifice quality, we believe jewelry is an investment and should be well made, and always certified.
Services
More recently, Alexis has decided to join the family business, leaving a lucrative and promising IT job in Atlanta, Georgia in order to bring her skills and expertise to Blue Diamond Jewelers. Coming from years of software sales experience, she longed to become a part of something that held true meaning, and what better avenue than the very business she grew about with?
At Blue, its all about you! We are here to serve you, being custom jewelers, beautiful pieces below are some of our custom designs. Let us know what you are interested and set up an appointment with us by giving us a ring or shooting us an email. We have promotions going on right now and we would love to see how we can make you happy with one of these treasures.
Do you want a piece that perhaps you just can't seem to find anywhere? It is almost as if you have this great idea and there isn't a single line out there the has anything like it. Let's just say we have received requests as unique as the hurricane symbol, if you dream it, we can make you a piece that will last a lifetime.
Call to make an appointment or come right in! In an effort to make sure one of the owners is present for this sort of expertise, it is best to give us a heads up so that we may be able to provide an estimate onsite. We have local expert jewelers that will take good care of your piece, so you can rest assured it is in good hands.
Reviews (13)
Write a Review
Laurie Henley
May 25, 2022
My husband gave me a beautiful daimond necklace for Christmas so for my 30 th wedding anniversary I wanted a new band to add to my ring. I was ment to walk into the store that day I figured why not! Well I was in the right place at the right time I got more then I ever dreamed. So perfect so friendly had a great visit with people from NY my ring is beyond what I was looking for. Thank you lady's my anniversary is not till July 16 th and I already have my perfect ring
Pat Gallus
Mar 26, 2022
I was initially happy with this family owned business. I ordered a 3 stone garnet ring with 14k gold. I have had it for just a little over a month. I was washing my hands and it bumped my wedding band on the other hand. I only paid $500.00 for it. My birthstone. I called Blue Diamond Jewelers. They would not replace the stone. They stated I may have bumped it before and didn't know it.

They have know warranty! Will not pay them to reset stone on a ring I do not wear regularly. Any other business clothing, cars, ear buds, phones, would take care of something a month old! Go else where!
Kelly Seyler
Mar 10, 2022
My teenage son was shopping for a gold rope chain and we stopped in at Blue Diamond Jewelers and were pleasantly surprised with their excellent service and high quality gold jewelry. We ordered a heavy, solid 14K gold chain that arrived in just a couple days rope chain. I was thrilled when I picked it up - the chain is gorgeous! We will definitely be shopping here again.
Alex McK
Dec 31, 2021
I just recently purchased an engagement ring from this store and the service was professional and consultative. They really listened to my needs, and instead of trying to force the most expensive stuff in the store, they let me pick and choose what was best for me. 10/10 would recommend to anyone looking for that special gift, for a special someone.
Matt Haftke
Oct 01, 2021
This family owned/ran business was a such a pleasure to work with! Getting an engagement ring is very stressful, but working with Blue Diamond Jewelers gave me relief and confidence in my decision. I recommend this place to all my friends and family
Nathaly Zohlandt
Sep 22, 2021
My husband and I just happened upon this jeweler by chance, and it was such a blessing! We were just window shopping and found our way inside; from the very beginning we were treated with nothing but kindness. Alexis, Nicole and Kathy really made us feel like family! They were so incredibly helpful and friendly, this was the best experience we have ever had going to a jeweler; they were very informational and were able to help us stick to our budget.

Their custom pieces are some of the most beautiful and unique I've seen; both from online stores and local. It was an absolute pleasure to be able to support such a wonderful family owned business!
Joseph Beyer
Sep 18, 2021
Blue Diamond Jewelers is exceptional! Alexis and Nicole took the time to go over options to design the perfect wedding ring for my wife and helped me pick my band as well. We are now current customers and look forward to working with them more. My wife feels very comfortable and trusts their family business. We both highly recommend them to others.
Eric Heavener
Aug 18, 2021
Loved my experience at Blue Diamond! I walked in with an idea and they made it to a reality! What makes it even better? It's family owned and operated. I will definitely be back!
Cecilia Trinh
Jul 28, 2021
If you're looking for ultimate high quality jewelry and want to experience superior service you can expect all that and more at Blue Diamond. What is important to me when giving a jeweler my loyalty is: quality, value, honesty and integrity. This sums up Blue Diamond. Here you will find one of a kind top of the line pieces or have the owners at Blue Diamond customize your collection.

They will go above and beyond to ensure your customized collection exceeds your expectations. I LOVE every piece I have acquired from them! Their goal is to earn your lifelong loyalty.give them a chance and you can thank me later. You're welcome!
Michelle K.
Jun 24, 2021
I am so pleased with the customer service from Blue Diamond Jewelers! From the initial consultation to the final decision, Alexis and her team were fantastic. I was shopping around for a gift for myself to celebrate a milestone birthday and knew that I'd be in good hands with Blue Diamond Jewelers. I explained to Alexis exactly what I was looking for in terms of carat size and the type of gemstone I wanted for my newest right hand ring.

She kept in great contact and was able to send me pictures of different options for the setting of the ring and answered ALL of my questions. I would highly recommend this jeweler to anyone in FL or in the country as they also ship their custom items to your home if you don't live anywhere near Coconut Point Mall (FL.) When it comes to investing in a piece of fine jewelry for yourself or for others, quality, customer service and an overall positive experience is all that I need to stay loyal to a jeweler.

Blue Diamond Jewelers has it all! Looking forward to working with them again soon! By the way, I'm in love with the co-owner's dog, Midas. He's got the sweetest demeanor and blue eyes to match their brand. If you're ever in the area, stop on by and you might be lucky enough to be greeted by this handsome fella! :)
Charles Rizzo
Jun 04, 2021
I had an opportunity to meet one of the sales folks from Blue Diamond at work some time ago. Vicki and I started talking about engagement rings and she invited me to come down and take a look at some rings, she was confident that they would have something for that special moment. I took the trip to the store and was so grateful I did! That is where I met Nichole and Alexis and felt at ease right away about my purchase!

They have incredible knowledge about design and their business as a whole, they have a passion for what they do! When we stop in to buy other fine jewelry from the wide selection at the store they always remember our names when we come in. And, if you are wonder. she said yes and now is my Wife. To our friends at Blue Diamond thank you for everything, we are your loyal customers!
Lindy Strodel
May 17, 2021
While at Coconut Point Mall, you must stop at Blue Diamond Jewelers! Be prepared to enter a world of distinctive elegance where your eyes will dance in delight at the luster of their pearls, the sparkle of diamonds exhibiting personality and movement and everything in between. I was charmed by learning this is a family owned business with extensive history!

I relish in purchasing jewelry that matches my personality and budget while knowing that it's a distinctive piece that looks like it was designed just for me. Jewelry repairs or start from scratch design with the store owners, mother and daughter team will ensure that the result will reflect just what you imagined. It is such a treat to shop there. If you're like me, you're eyes will be dancing a "happy dance " and you'll feel like you just met some new friends!
Grant Wise
Feb 22, 2020
I have to say I have had good luck in the past using Blue diamond jewelers for custom jewelry. So it was a no brainer to go with them on a recent project. The only problem I could see would be the short amount of time I had to have this piece of jewelry completed and ready for a 60th birthday. I worked with Nicole and came up with a design and a plan to try to complete it on time.

I wasn't disappointed! Blue Diamond not only had it ready on time actually a day early and what a beautiful job they did. My friend is so happy with the necklace pendant. I'll be back for more jewelry in the future! Thanks again!