Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Coin & Jewelry Gallery University This piece features 9.5 Cts of hand carved green tourmaline as well as 1.29 Ct TW of baguette and round diamonds. This is a one of a kind piece. After 26 years National Coin Investors has changed its name to Coin and Jewelry Gallery, now with two locations to better serve you. Coin and Jewelry Gallery has been owned & operated since 1981 by Ann and Vince Santostefano.
Follow us
Reviews (16)
Write a Review
Matthew Timberlake
Feb 06, 2022
Dave worked with my fiance and I to design and create a beautiful and unique engagement ring. We will definitely be back when it's time for wedding rings.
John Fairless
Jan 25, 2022
I thoroughly enjoy and appreciate going in to trade with Coin and Jewelry Gallery. I am a "dabbler" rather than a serious coin collector, but I am always treated respectfully and get a very fair and consistent price for my coins. I will keep coming back again and again as long as they will have me!
Andy Wilson
Jan 15, 2022
Excellent customer service. Wanted a custom piece made for my mother and David Hill was extremely helpful and produced a beautiful product. Highly recommend.
Andrew Coffey
Dec 22, 2021
Better quality than online jewelry retailers and knowledgeable staff can help customize pieces with fast turnaround. Top notch craftsmanship on service/repair items. Great local shop.
Lane A.
Dec 21, 2021
Fantastic service, friendly, knowledgeable, and very fair. The have an impressive selection of coins and jewelry and it's a great place to trade bullion. David is an incredibly talented jeweler with beautiful custom work and repairs and is a pleasure to work with. Vince, Ann, and David are great people and the store is the best in town.
Jesse Whiting
Dec 05, 2021
Called asking them to hold something for me I was right down the road they sold it before I got there can't depend on this company to do anything if it's in your benefit they're all about them lost a lifetime customer will only be shopping at coin kingdom from here on
Rob Lewis
Nov 18, 2021
Knowledgeable, friendly, Great experience, totally awesome. Made the drive from Jacksonville worth it, will shop here again soon
Dan Dasclo
Nov 07, 2021
I have lived many lives through trial and error. Anne and Vince have helped convert "easter eggs" from being "all in one basket, " too the sweet melody of "Jing-a-ling-a-ling" in a pants' pocket. Their forethought was even so kind to start a piggy bank for our new born. Simply, thank you both.
Keri R.
Sep 19, 2021
Great customer service, and a wonderful job resizing a ring for me. It looks beautiful! Much nicer than when I dropped it off- perfectly polished!
Jimmy Lowry
Aug 18, 2021
The team at Coin & Jewelry have once again far exceeded our expectations! Dave has always treated us like family. They have gone out of their way to get us what we wanted. I highly recommend!
Tim Skane
Jul 19, 2021
Needed a custom made Fantasy Football championship ring and Dave delivered! Love the piece and can't recommend him high enough! Thanks Dave!
R. Pettie
Jul 14, 2021
My wife and I were looking for a 'perfect' 25th Anniversary ring. We thought, quite wrongly, that custom jewelry was more expensive than what we would find in-stock at other local jewelers. We went to chain stores and even tried antique rings in Micanopy. We never found that 'perfect' ring for her elsewhere. I decided to take her with me to Coin & Jewelry Gallery and that turned out to be a great idea!

The staff was knowledgeable and didn't try to upsell us into something she didn't like or wouldn't wear. We found the perfect ring! Coin & Jewelry Gallery has great jewelry at great prices!
Lois Lowery
Apr 27, 2021
I'm in the process of having my engagement ring stone and wedding band stones reset into one band, and Millhopper was recommended to me. I'm glad they're doing the work. David is very knowledgeable, professional, and very nice to work with on this. I tried on a prototype he made, and I am so looking forward to the finished product. I just picked up my ring today.

If I could give more then 5 stars, I would. The workmanship is exceptional, and David did a beautiful job. I will recommend Millhopper Coin and Jewelry to anyone. Thank you all for your dedication and compassion.
Tmullersman
Mar 17, 2021
If you need an engagement ring I highly recommend visiting Dave. He is extremely knowledgeable and skilled and has great deals on the highest quality stones. Don't buy an engagement ring without going to see Dave!
Paul Zane
Mar 05, 2021
This is where you go when you want something done at the highest quality, at a fair price, and done right the very first time! This is where you go when you have an eight million year old piece of carbon that you want to give to the love of your life and the jewelry store in the mall just isn't going to cut it. Go ask for Dave and tell him exactly what you want.

This man will take a roughly drawn picture on a napkin and turn it into a one of a kind setting that will far exceed your wildest expectations. While I do wish their online presence was bigger all you need to do is call and ask for Dave and he will take care of you from start to finish. They also buy and sell coins.
Cory Hodes
Nov 24, 2019
After months of researching online and searching in other jewelry stores for an engagement ring, I was able to pick out a diamond in one trip with the help of Dave at The Coin & Jewelry Gallery! Dave is incredibly knowledgeable and he was able to answer all of my questions. He had dozens of diamonds in my price range that met my criteria, and he made the process very easy and painless. Dave did not have any bands that met my criteria, but he was able to order some to choose from and had them in the very next day! I will be back for future purchases. I would give The Coin & Jewelry Gallery 6 stars if I could!