Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
John Herold Jewelers With more than 30 years of experience as a Master Bench Jeweler, John works in the tradition of the old world craftsmen, who taught him the secrets which have been passed on through the generations. His eye for style and beauty is second to none, as can be seen when designing and creating that unique custom jewelry for you. If you have been searching for that perfect jewelry item that you just can't seem to find anywhere, discuss it with John. He will create it specifically for you, to meet your most exacting specifications.
Follow us
Services
John Herold Jewelers provides full service jewelry repairs on the premises, your jewelry does not leave our store. From resizing rings or repairing broken chains to creating original pieces of jewelry, our jewelers are expert craftsmen who will take absolute care in repairing your jewelry.
Our Four C's of Diamonds guide can help you decide on the most important factors when shopping for a diamond. The word carat derives from the word carob, a Mediterranean seed, which has an extremely consistent weight for measuring. The greater the carat weight, the rarer, and more valuable the diamond becomes.
Celebrating 100 years, CITIZEN, a pioneer in watchmaking and innovative technology, promotes excellence and creativity with a deep-rooted respect for craftsmanship. CITIZEN advocates 'Better Starts Now, ' searching for and accomplishing goals that better our lives. In this respect, CITIZEN aligns with organizations and personalities that reflect the values of the brand including the Citizen Naismith Trophy, National Merit Scholarship and Good360. As a 'citizen of the world' we bear the responsibility to help cultivate positive change and on-going evolution to our craft.
For over 60 years, Honora has stood for value and quality in the jewelry industry. Today Honora specializes in bringing the very best in Freshwater Pearls since they arrived on the market over 20 years ago. Honora is the largest importer of fine Freshwater Pearls in the United States and uses these astounding cultured pearls to create colorful and affordable pearl jewelry.
Reviews (14)
Write a Review
Judith Buckley
Jun 15, 2022
Very attentive, polite, fast service! I went there to sell some jewelry and to buy some other items. John has beautiful designed jewelry! Highly recommend
Matt Calabrese
Feb 26, 2022
I had four watches needing batteries/repair and looking for a birthday gift for my wife. John was personable, asked what my wife liked in the form of a necklace and helped me pick out what is now my wife's favorite necklace. 14k gold with three dangling diamonds. I've never seen a chain, let alone the diamonds, sparkle in such a stunning, eye catching way.

Oh and by the way, the watches were ready for pick up the following day. Thank you John for making my wife's birthday so special She's still thanking me for her necklace three days later
Elle Hays
Jan 29, 2022
My entire transaction went very smoothly. I would highly recommend John Herold Jewelers to everyone. Their recommendations were spot on, didn't try to upsell something i didn't want.
Dani Cohen
Nov 26, 2021
We couldn't recommend John Herald Jewelers more! Their customer service is top notch and you can tell how much they care about each customer. Jessica was incredibly helpful, super nice, friendly and accommodating. We had such a positive experience there getting wedding bands and my ring appraised! Will definitely continue to go there in the future!
Maddie Geiger
Sep 21, 2021
Had an amazing and easy experience at john herold jewelers! i will be sure to go back whenever i have a jewelry repair or need a quick purchase!
Maureen Feeley
Sep 03, 2021
Beautiful Jewelry store in Randolph New Jersey! Jessica is a gem herself, and John is a class act. Would highly recommend.
Robert O'Donnell
Jul 19, 2021
Great Experience. They were Very Nice. Very Skilled and the Return Time was Very Quick!
Susan Spal
Jul 17, 2021
John Herold Jewelers reworked my ankle bracelet which is made up of gem stones and gold wire. John repaired my ankle bracelet ex- peditiously. His staff are friendly and knowledgeable. Susan Spal
Diana Burke
Jun 30, 2021
I found John Herold Jewelers to be most helpful for finding what I wanted. Jessica is wonderful and pleasant and made me feel quite comfortable. She is easy to talk to. My husband was pleased with the help he received and got me a beautiful gift for our anniversary. We have purchased there many times and will be back.
Pat D.
Jun 21, 2021
I've been a customer of John's for over 20 years and consider him a friend as well. We enjoy shopping there, John always has beautiful and unique pieces. I am in Florida now and have shopped from here because I know I can trust that whatever I purchase is quality with a fair price tag.
Helene Elbaum
Jun 18, 2021
I couldn't think of a more professional, honest, and skilled jeweler like John Herold to send my now fiance to purchase my engagement ring. I was speechless with the final product. The ring was breathtaking! John and his staff were patient, personable and so accommodating. Highly recommend! John is a true gem!
Virginia Jensen
May 27, 2021
Excellent work on a ring I requested. My husband just passed and this was his earring with a stone I wanted transferred to a ring and it came out beautiful. My family and I loved the work they did. The staff was patient helping me figure out what would look good. I would definitely recommend this place.
Brittany Donaway
Apr 03, 2021
We unfortunately had to postpone our 2020 wedding due to the pandemic, but we're still having a civil ceremony in November. John and his staff managed to bring excitement back into the wedding planning experience. You'll find the best customer service and the most knowledgeable employees. Thanks again for everything John Herold Jewelers!
Carmela Hoffman
Mar 26, 2021
I was very well pleased with the two employees of Herold Jewelers that I interacted with to have my wedding band sized. They also ordered two rings that I liked in a catalog, so that I could see them and try them on. I would happy highly recommend their services and their products.