Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Mc Coy Jewelers McCoy Jewelers came to life in November of 1992. Dreaming of one day owning a store, but not thinking it was possible, out of the blue Dayna McCoy received a call asking if she wanted to buy a store in downtown Bartlesville. Before she knew what hit her, Dayna was the proud owner of McCoy Jewelers. Since 1992 Dayna and her husband Larry have enjoyed seeing their hard work grow into a new store, three times as large as when they began.

Second generation, Matt McCoy took over ownership in January of 2011 and plans to continue providing the high level of service and merchandise McCoy Jewelers' clients have become accustomed to in the previous years.
Follow us
Services
Our Jeweler, Matt McCoy, is a Jewelers of America Certified Master bench Jeweler with over 30 years experience. If you don't live in or close to Bartlesville, no problem, send us your jewelry and we'll repair it and send it back to you.
Our Four C's of Diamonds guide can help you decide on the most important factors when shopping for a diamond. The word carat derives from the word carob, a Mediterranean seed, which has an extremely consistent weight for measuring. The greater the carat weight, the rarer, and more valuable the diamond becomes.
Some people want to buy the biggest diamond possible. Is this always the right choice? The larger the diamond, chances are the more inclusions it likely has, and because it's larger, these inclusions are typically even more visible than on a smaller diamond. But most importantly, if the diamond cut isn't proportioned correctly, it won't return the maximum amount of light through the top of the diamond. This illustrates that no matter how large the diamond, its cut and proportions determine how brilliant the diamond really is.
Solitaire settings are great if you have a stunning singular stone that has been passed down through the generations as an heirloom, many choose to display it in a classic Solitaire setting. This setting generally allows for the maximum amount of sparkle by allowing light to pass in through the bottom sections of the ring.
Reviews (18)
Write a Review
Christopher Gehringer
Jun 15, 2022
Best Jewelery Store in Bartlesville! Handled appraisals efficiently and professionally. Kind and considerate staff. Will be returning to discuss some custom jewelery options.
Amanda Loud
Jun 06, 2022
I was in Bartlesville visiting my father when I discovered my ring which I have worn for 40+ years was missing a small stone and needed repair. McCoy's fixed it quickly and beautifully. I received excellent customer service and recommend this jeweler.
Aaron Majors
Apr 24, 2022
Amazing customer service! I live 3 hours away and they worked with me to come in on a Saturday when they are normally closed and helped walk me through everything. I would highly recommend them to anyone! Will not go anywhere else!
Lee Hamilton
Apr 22, 2022
The folks at McCoy Jewelers are efficient and cost competitive. They make you feel relaxed and a part of the family and very informative on their jewelry or repairs.
Jesse Rinck
Jan 19, 2022
Very professional and polite staff with a beautiful selection of jewelry. Very thorough in their profession if you have any questions. I definitely recommend seeing them for purchasing
Martha Ambler
Jan 16, 2022
We turn to McCoy Jewelers for anything from jewelry repair to fine diamonds, they are the best! Fair, honest and competively priced, they have been our go-to jewelry store for many years.
Donna Thomas
Jan 06, 2022
First time going here. They were very friendly and had the ring I had started looking for. The price I wanted to pay was within my budget. It was sized in just a few days. Love the ring. Talked to them about resizing a ring and it was at a very reasonable price. I will be going here from now on.
Malcolm Hare
Dec 24, 2021
Friendly and prompt service that's very helpful. Highly recommended.
Jennie
Dec 06, 2021
Matt redesigned some jewelry from my mother and grandmother into beautiful creations. He really took the time to understand what I wanted. I am soooo happy with the pieces.
Kimberly Bunde
Nov 26, 2021
Love the work they did to repair my grandmother's wedding ring. I absolutely love it and they was so helpful and friendly I highly recommend them
LaTrisha Dowell
Nov 25, 2021
My mom gave me her first solitaire diamond and another solitaire that my dad gave her! My dad passed away Dec 2020. I wanted to do something special with those diamonds! McCoys custom designed me the most beautiful ring! I will cherish it always.
Sallem Tullis
Nov 23, 2021
Shopping at McCoy Jewelers was a wonderful experience! The owner was fabulous to work with. She helped me find exactly what I needed. The store was neat and clean and well kept. The jewelry was very well displayed. I will definitely be shopping here again!
Susan Murray
Nov 20, 2021
When my husband of 43 yrs suddenly passed away I knew I wanted to make a keepsake of his diamond wedding band. Matt and Laurie made that dream happen. Here is my forever ring made from those diamonds. They can make your dreams and wishes come true too
Leslie White
Nov 15, 2021
I had my wedding ring resized. It now fits me again perfectly and looks great.
Maryann Cole
Oct 25, 2021
I took my wedding ring set into McCoy's Jewelers to have the prongs replaced. Besides doing that, they cleaned my ring and I wasn't expecting that. It was a wonderful surprise! The new prongs look great and. even after 46 years of marriage. my ring looks brand new! I recommend McCoy's to anyone who needs help with a jewelry need.
Lynda Monges
Oct 23, 2021
I have take 2 rings in to be fixed and they do a wonderful job. They are always super friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend them for jewelry repair!
Karen H.
Jan 23, 2016
I have a lot of jewelry and have purchased many items from McCoy jewelers. They are top notch and the work they do on repairs and adjustments cannot be beat. The staff is accommodating and always contributes and enhances decisions about making the item better. I have since moved to another state, but will be sending my jewelry to them. Matt and Dana are the best in design and workmanship. Thank you!
Ppool K.
Feb 19, 2015
Won't ever do business again with them. Was happy with the service years ago but the business has changed and is very poor. Had an appraisal done that was so far off I went to two other jewelers who said there was no way they could make a ring like it for the appraisal value. Went back and they weren't confident they could either! But wouldn't change their appraisal, makes sense.go it reappraised and there was a $2,000 difference which aligned with the other jewelers. Service was also poor, lady was very arrogant. They over price everything and make average jewelry compared to other jewelers in town.