Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Moyer Fine Jewelers For over 40 years, the Moyer name has been synonymous with trust, quality and incredible customer service. At Moyer, expect to find the Indianapolis area's best engagement rings, fine jewelry and Swiss watches.
Services
Our store in Carmel, Indiana offers something for everyone, no matter what you're looking for, or the price range you're staying within. Find your style, from classic and timeless to trendy and popular, in our fashion department. You'll find only the highest-quality diamonds in our bridal lounge. And our watch department has some of the most renowned Swiss names, but also an extensive and very popular selection of rare and sought-after pre-owned models.Our founder, Dan Moyer, began selling turquoise jewelry in high school and college, eventually investing in gold and jewels that he sold in sororities and beauty salons.
As far as engagement ring styles, our bridal department has an extensive variety of looks from timeless classics to trendy looks from Pinterest or Instagram. From 3-stone engagement rings and solitaire engagement rings to vintage engagement rings and halo engagement rings, we like to give our brides the most comprehensive selection when it comes to choosing the perfect ring.
Why have one diamond in your engagement ring when you can have three?! Three-stone engagement rings can have any combination of diamond shapes with either all three diamonds being the same shape or the two side stones being different shapes than the center diamond. Gemstones can also be incorporated into three stone designs!
Twisted engagement rings, or criss-cross engagement rings, are categorized as such because of the "twist" in the shank or band of the ring. In many designs, the twist will have diamonds on either one or both of the twisted parts. Please note, all styles (with the exception of complete engagement rings) featured in this category are priced without the center diamond.
Reviews (10)
Write a Review
Kim Fine
Jun 11, 2022
Moyer Fine Jewelers is my favorite jewelry store. The shopping experience is truly pleasurable with a modern, glamorous decor and a welcoming staff. They have an extensive selection for every budget. Mandy Souers is so friendly and helpful. With Mandy's knowledge of the products and style, she is able to pick out the perfect items. Mandy was instrumental in helping my daughter and future son in law design a gorgeous engagement ring. Mandy helped my daughter narrow her selections, shared her knowledge of diamonds and settings, and made her feel like the special princess she is! Mandy then coordinated with my future son in law to pick out the perfect diamond for them. They were thrilled with the experience.
Omar Ahmad
May 30, 2022
I was looking for a very specific style of watch that I was having little luck finding nationwide. Scott at Moyer Fine Jewelers did more footwork in locating a suitable piece for me than any other AD I had worked with. Excellent communication and service throughout the whole experience. Highly recommended!
Liz Mershimer
May 14, 2022
We went to Moyers to "look" at anniversary bands and that is where we met Tyler. He was beyond wonderful! Very attentive and always listening to what we were saying. He is very knowledgeable in his craft and it more than showed in how he helped us select and narrow down our choices. We found the perfect band and came back to get a "matching" mount for my engagement ring stone. Tyler helped with the selection again, and I am over the moon with the pairing. Truly the best experience! Highly recommend working with Tyler! Not only is he a great salesperson, but he truly cares that you are more than satisfied with your purchase.
Lexi Schlink
May 08, 2022
Okay. this was our first time looking at engagement rings and Tyler was the most AMAZING person to help us do it! We had a perfect experience from start to finish, he knew exactly how to help me find the perfect one and made my boyfriend and I double over in laughter! I thought ring shopping was going to be stressful and full of important decisions. Tyler made it simple and fun.

If you're in the market for anything bridal, he's your guy. Experienced, knowledgeable, and personable-everything you want in someone helping you with something as important as this! Thanks again TYLER!
Caitlin K.
Apr 26, 2022
Moyer Fine Jewelers has quickly become my family jeweler from my engagement & wedding rings, gifts for milestones, watches, and everything in between. The staff knows so much about their product and spend lots of time educating the buyer (aka me). Everyone is accommodating, low pressure, and I know I'm buying quality product. I always leave happy and am so thankful to have a jeweler I can trust! Plus, the golden retrievers that hang around don't hurt!
Aaron Curtis
Apr 12, 2022
My experience with Moyer Fine Jewelers would not, in any way, be complete without mentioning Mandy. Truly superb and exceptional experience from her through the many purchases I've had there. I've always received nothing but extraordinary service to which makes it virtually impossible to go anywhere else. Well done.
Kevin Avelino
Mar 14, 2022
I went into Moyer with a diamond that I had purchased a year and a half ago and was hoping to have a band made for it. I walked into Moyer and Mandy immediately greeted me and assisted me with the process. She spent a great amount of time showing me different types of rings and helped me create my dream ring. She was always available to answer any questions that I had.

I also had a situation arise where I needed the ring a couple of days sooner that expected and Mandy was able to make it happen. If you're going to Moyer, be sure to ask for Mandy! You will not regret working with her and going to Moyer! Thank you so much Mandy. Because of you, I was able to give my fiance the perfect engagement.
Brian McNicholas
Feb 19, 2022
I cannot say enough wonderful things about Moyer. I went in to look at watches and had an excellent experience. The sales associate was kind and helpful and let me try on anything I was interested in. I felt no pressure to have to buy something but ended up with a gorgeous new timepiece. The facility is very upscale and I felt like every customer was important to them. I will definitely be visiting them again next time the itch for a new watch arises!
Eli Beaverson Golf
Jan 22, 2022
Fantastic experience with Bill purchasing a watch for my birthday! He was extremely knowledgeable and we were able to find a unique piece within budget. Will absolutely be recommending Moyer to anyone who asks!
Evan D.
Oct 17, 2021
I've purchased a few watches from Moyer and have had a great experience every time.they have an awesome selection of real "watch geek" watches that you won't find anywhere else in Indiana. They've even resized a few bracelets at no cost on watches I didn't purchase from Moyer. Big thanks to Jenny, Bill, and Scott for the great service.