Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Peter Indorf Jewelers There's an evolution happening in custom jewelry services, and Peter Indorf is leading the way. Following a successful, 44-plus year retail history in Connecticut, the company is expanding its services to the Space Coast in Florida, and looking to change the way clients experience custom-made jewelry. The name has changed to Peter Indorf Designs. Since 1972, Peter Indorf has developed strong relationships with clients in the Greater New Haven area and along the Connecticut shoreline, providing beautiful, unique designs, and finding creative solutions to jewelry challenges.
Services
Peter Indorf Designs specializes in jewelry services. Consider us your personal jeweler, attending to your needs with professionalism, ethics and consumer protection. Our highly experienced staff is well trained not only in finding the perfect gift, but also in how to care and maintain your pieces throughout the years. If you have any questions regarding custom jewelry design and the personal services we offer, please contact us at 321-914-0118 or Contact Us.
Everyone needs a jewelry appraisal at some point, with jewelry insurance coverage valuation being the most common. Other reasons are the desire to sell your jewelry or give away your jewelry to your heirs or in some cases division of property due to divorce or other reasons. We offer a free introductory consultation to ascertain the scope of the appraisal assignment and to provide our expert advice and free estimates of any work being considered.
Using a combination of state-of-the-art technology and old-fashioned handmade craftsmanship, we can restyle your old jewelry into something new and beautiful, or create a special design using your gems or ours. Special order proposals include either a hand drawn design or a three-dimensional color rendering that is so realistic you will swear it is a photograph!
Hand engraving is a specialized fine art that offers many creative options. We can produce an engraved locket for your daughter's 16th birthday, a man's signet ring to commemorate a college graduation, special personalized messages inside of rings and more.
Reviews (13)
Write a Review
Mimi Blair
Apr 08, 2022
I called Peter to inquire about getting an appraisal on some pieces. I can already tell from our initial conversation & emails that I'm working with a true honest professional! I look forward to meeting him in person & I've already been convinced of his quality & professionalism by his wonderful reviews & kind demeanor through our initial conversations.

I'd like to add to my review. After meeting with Peter he exceeded my expectations with his vast knowledge impeccable craftsmanship not to mention his wonderful demeanor! He's always answered any of my crazy questions without making me feel inferior for asking! I feel like I've met a dear friend I can trust in a business that doesn't always have the most forthright folks. Peter is a fabulous jewelry designer & can make practically anything for you!

Talk about BESPOKE! He's literally had couples just tell him or scribble a design & he makes it come to life in his pieces! What a remarkable talent he is! I'm so happy he's come to Brevard county!
David Leffell
Feb 11, 2022
Superb custom design, very customer focused attention, and beautiful execution on the pendant. We initially discussed what I had in mind and the final result was stunning! We have been customers for 30 years and followed Peter once he relocated out of state.
Susannah Vining
Jan 06, 2022
We contacted Peter with the idea of having a custom piece designed for me incorporating my children's birthstones. Peter was immediately responsive. He listened to my thoughts and responded with information, suggestions and guidance. Before long, we narrowed it down to two designs for which he provided detailed proposals. Once we commited to one, Peter got right to work and delivered the finished product earlier than promised. The jewelery is absolutely stunning and working with Peter was a pleasure from start to finish. I look forward to the next time!
Donaciano Ponce De Leon
Dec 29, 2021
Peter is amazing. He has created two custom rings for me, and I have received nothing but awes and gasps. He really takes the time to learn about his clients so that he can make their visions a reality.
Richard Bernhardt
Jun 19, 2021
Peter appraised three items for my wife. We were very impressed with his knowledge, expertise, professionalism, and friendliness. He provided a detailed report on each piece of jewelry, as well as a great photograph of the pieces. I highly recommend his services for appraisals, and questions about jewelry!
Carol Maglitta
Feb 01, 2021
Peter was a dream to work with - so kind, thoughtful, creative and responsive. I love my Kaitlyn ring! I've gotten so many compliments - people just love it! I'm forever grateful. Thank you Peter!
Kelly Richards
Jun 15, 2020
Peter made a beautiful Ring with my grand babies birthstones. A birthday present from my husband. A stunning ring. Lovely design, gorgeous gems and just couldn't have been better! He is very easy to work with and has a true passion which shows in the quality and uniqueness of the pieces he creates!
David J.
May 20, 2020
My wife and I have been married for 35 years. Peter crafted our wedding rings from a concept that we literally scribbled out on a piece of scrap paper. We never (well, very seldom) took them off over all those years and both had shown some wear. We sent the rings to Peter for restoration and the results are spectacular! We feel like newlyweds again.

And why not? The rings and engagement diamond sparkle like new. Peter was as helpful today as he was when he originally designed the rings. I am sure that if they start to wear out again in 35 years, we'll be sending them back to Peter Indorf again. He is not just a jeweler, but a true artisan.
Kate Lombardo
Jan 03, 2020
A few months ago, I reached out to Peter to see if he could create a ring that I had been in love with for years. I couldn't have had a more positive experience. He responded to my emails incredibly quickly, offered a very reasonable price, and crafted the ring with incredible workmanship. All of my expectations were exceeded. Thank you, Peter!
Sarah A.
Oct 16, 2019
Working with Peter has been great. He has been highly professional in helping me design a custom ring. The craftsmanship is beautiful and his price is very reasonable.
Zach Helmberger
Apr 05, 2019
Peter is an exceptional jewelry designer who helped me create the perfect engagement ring for my new fiancee! She is absolutely in love with the design and I could not be more pleased with how it all turned out. Peter conducts business with patience and class while working with you to create the perfect look and feel for whatever you are looking for. This is a no brainer 5 star review and I look forward to working with Peter in the future!
Karen B.
Feb 21, 2019
Peter found the perfect engagement setting for a stone we provided. He was so easy to work with from outside the country, communicating regularly and thoroughly through emails. The final piece was exactly as envisioned and delivered on time. His pricing was fair, and he even worked us on some pieces we wanted to sell. Highly recommend Peter Indorf Designs.
Catrina B.
Nov 06, 2013
I have been to both locations (this designer has one in New Haven, too) and was surprised that they didn't have more interesting pieces, given that it's a designer shop. There was more to choose from that was unusual in New Haven in their shop there, I should note. They have a lot of the standard gemstones in prong settings, but there were a few unusual pieces.

My boyfriend took me in here to find something special for my birthday. We found one pair of earrings that we both really liked, but the problem with them was just that they had short wires that didn't fit my ears well. I was surprised that, as a jeweler, they did not offer to replace the wires with one of the many styles of gold leverbacks that are available, even if it cost more.

They kept pushing the little rubber stoppers as the solution to the issue. I should note that when I went to the New Haven location of the store and noted the same issue with another pair of earrings, the salesperson quickly pointed out that they could put any kind of wire on that I wanted, and even got out the book to show me the options and prices.

As a result, we walked away from the Madision store. If you're looking for fine gold and pure silver designer work and are in the Madison area, I would recommend this store. But push for what you want if something needs to be changed. As I learned from their other location, anything is possible.