Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
We are a family-owned and operated jewelry store serving Mill Valley since 1994. Our legacy began with founders Carl and Susan Priolo and continues through their children, Lucas and Sophie. We specialize in custom creations and bespoke designs tailored to individual stories. Our team of skilled artisans combines generations of craftsmanship with modern innovation. We curate pieces from renowned designers like Sethi Couture and Suzanne Kalan while maintaining the highest standards of quality. Every piece we offer reflects our commitment to artistry and enduring value.

We prioritize personalized service, ensuring clients feel supported through every step of their jewelry journey. Our expertise spans engagement rings, anniversary gifts, and everyday wear that celebrates lifes milestones. We take pride in transforming heirlooms into contemporary designs that honor tradition while embracing new narratives. Our dedication to transparency and ethical sourcing underscores every transaction. We strive to make jewelry shopping an intimate, joyful experience rooted in trust and creativity.
Highlights and features
  • We offer 29 years of family-owned expertise in jewelry design and craftsmanship.
  • Our custom creations are individually crafted by skilled artisans for unique personalization.
  • We source only ethically obtained diamonds and gemstones of the highest quality.
  • Our team provides transparent pricing and detailed guidance throughout the purchasing process.
  • We guarantee lifetime maintenance and repair services for all purchased pieces.
Services
Custom Creations
We transform client visions into reality through collaborative design sessions. From initial sketches to final setting, our artisans ensure precise execution of personalized details. Each piece is crafted to become an heirloom, blending emotional significance with technical excellence for generations to cherish.
Designer Jewelry
We curate collections from renowned artists like Alex Sepkus and Moritz Glik. These pieces combine innovative design with exceptional craftsmanship, offering clients access to exclusive styles not found elsewhere. Our selections cater to diverse tastes, from minimalist everyday wear to statement occasion pieces.
Jewelry Repair
Our in-house goldsmiths provide expert restoration services for heirlooms and treasured pieces. We handle rhodium plating, prong tightening, and stone replacement with meticulous care. Our repair work maintains the original design integrity while ensuring long-term durability and safety.
Consultation Services
Our certified jewelers offer personalized guidance for selecting or designing pieces. We educate clients on diamond grading, metal types, and care instructions to empower informed decisions. This service ensures perfect alignment between client preferences and final purchases.
Engagement Rings
We specialize in creating unique engagement rings that reflect each couples story. Our process includes diamond sourcing, setting design, and metal selection. Every ring is crafted to symbolize enduring love through exceptional quality and personalized details.
Reviews (7)
Ari K.
Jun 11, 2022 Report
I had a wedding EMERGENCY--a stone fell out of my ring the day before! Sofia Jewelry was able to take care of the problem and get the stone re-set within a few hours which was such a relief. Such gracious amazing people. AND they shined it up so it looks gorgeous! Thank you so much!
Polly C.
May 27, 2022 Report
I've moved many times in my life and my lesson has been to pick jewelry stores based on service. Sofia Jewelry is the best I've ever experienced. They somehow have mastered the art of selling with heart, kindness, and compassion. Jewelry is very personal and many pieces have stories. They embrace the stories and do everything they can to match the stories with your style with their artistry. It's really quite amazing. I've worked with them on sizing, designing custom rings to replicate old family pieces, and repairs.

From the minute you walk in the door they work with you to ensure you have a quality experience. You walk in their store and you feel like they know you, care about you and care about the stories of whatever jewelry you wear. They are truly the best jewelers and sales people I've ever worked with.
Diana C.
Feb 16, 2022 Report
The Sofia Jewelry team is as good as they come! Lucas and team are warm, professional, and experts in their craft. My husband and I brought in a diamond ring that has a ~130-year history in the family. Lucas revolutionized the ring into a new design and setting just as I had requested -- and my family is equally blown away by his work. As my husband and I left Sofia Jewelry with the revitalized ring, my husband said "it's just so nice doing business with people like Lucas." Sofia Jewelry epitomizes quality and care. Highly recommend!
Taylor W.
Jul 31, 2021 Report
I recently had a custom ring made at Sophia Jewelry downtown Mill Valley. Lucas was amazing in helping me duplicate a ring I had seen at an estate sale. We used metal and diamonds from a ring I already owned and created an exact replica of what I had in my mind. Lucas was super patient, we had several iterations of the ring and he was very careful to consider the width and the height of the ring as I was hoping it feel a certain way on my hand. - smooth and delicate but also substantial.

The thing about getting something made at Sophia Jewelry is that unlike other jewelers they have an artistic eye and incredible (and stylish) design sense. They are willing to work with you to develop a piece that is exactly what you envision and at a fair price point. Thank you Lucas and Team!
Sara C.
Feb 03, 2021 Report
My wedding ring broke several years ago and I had been working on a vision of what to do with the stones. Lucas answered my tentative email right away that yes, he could definitely recreate the style I was after. Every step he was a partner in the process, communicating quickly and openly, enthusiastically offering lots of options and letting me look at and try different stones, while also repurposing all of my old stones. He was so patient and open, truly a perfect experience. I could not be happier.
Suzanne B.
Dec 27, 2020 Report
I had several pieces of jewelry I needed to have repaired. How wonderful to have a (very reasonable) quote via email within an hour, super safe Covid-responsible drop off, and back in perfect condition within a week. I didn't look to buy anything, but will definitely go there the next time I'm in the market for a new piece. Lovely folks!
Kim L.
Dec 05, 2020 Report
I can not express enough thanks and gratitude to Sofia Jewlery. I took two rings to them to have the gem stones repurposed (marriage accrued but now divorced). Lucas and his team did a stunning job from design to completion. The overall vision and final product brought tears to my eyes. I highly recommend Sofia Jewelry for all your jewelry needs. They are kind, caring, thoughtful, generous, and creative! Thank you thank you!