Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Family-Owned Jewelry Store Since 1934
Since 1934, Westerly Jewelry has served as a trusted family-owned business dedicated to providing exceptional jewelry and personalized service. Our legacy began with Samuel Hirsch, who established the store in Westerly, Rhode Island, after emigrating from Poland. Over 75 years later, we continue to uphold the values of quality, integrity, and community that defined our founders. Our team includes a Graduate Gemologist from the Gemological Institute of America and a master jeweler with decades of experience, ensuring every customer receives expert guidance and craftsmanship. We specialize in fine jewelry, including diamonds, engagement rings, luxury watches, and precious metals, while offering repair services, free appraisals, and competitive pricing.Our commitment to the local community is reflected in our active involvement and personalized approach, treating every customer like family. With a combined 70 years of experience, Kevin Algiere and Sherry Ornberg prioritize transparency, quality, and customer satisfaction. We maintain rigorous health and safety standards, including curbside service, to ensure a comfortable shopping experience. As one of Westerlys longest-standing businesses, we blend tradition with modern expertise to deliver timeless beauty and value.
Services
Jewelry Repair
Engagement Rings
Watch Sales
Gold Buying
Appraisals
Diamond Grading
Precious Metal Sales
Watch Battery Replacement
Custom Design
Estate Jewelry
Details
- Year established: 1934
Highlights and features
- We offer 75+ years of expertise in fine jewelry and gemology.
- Our Graduate Gemologist provides professional, GIA-certified evaluations.
- Free appraisals and transparent pricing on all purchases.
- Community-focused service with personalized attention since 1934.
- In-house repairs and watch battery replacements at no charge.
Associations and certifications
- Gemological Institute of America (GIA)
Services
Jewelry Repair
Our master jeweler handles 99% of repairs in-house, including ring cleaning, stone setting checks, and watch battery replacements at no charge. With decades of experience, we ensure precision and durability for all jewelry types, from antique pieces to modern designs.
Diamond Grading
Leverage our Graduate Gemologists expertise to evaluate diamonds using the 4Cs (Cut, Color, Clarity, Carat). We provide detailed assessments of authenticity, quality, and value, ensuring informed decisions when buying or selling diamonds, with emphasis on AGS-certified standards.
Gold Buying
We offer competitive pricing for gold, silver, and platinum items, including jewelry, coins, and scrap. Our specialists determine purity and market value, paying based on current rates. Free appraisals and no obligation to sell ensure a transparent, stress-free experience.
Luxury Watch Sales
Explore a curated selection of new and pre-owned luxury watches from brands like Rolex, Bering, and Seiko. Our inventory includes Swiss-engineered timepieces, rugged designs, and sophisticated models, all backed by expert guidance to match your style and needs.
Custom Design
Collaborate with our artisans to create bespoke jewelry reflecting your unique vision. From engagement rings to heirloom restorations, we combine technical skill with creative insight to craft personalized pieces using high-quality materials and traditional techniques.
People
Kevin Algiere
President
Kevin Algiere, a master jeweler and Graduate Gemologist, has led Westerly Jewelry since 1999. With over 30 years of experience, he specializes in repairs, custom design, and community service as a reserve police officer.
Sherry Ornberg
Graduate Gemologist
Sherry Ornberg, a GIA-certified Graduate Gemologist, brings decades of expertise in diamond grading and jewelry evaluation. She ensures customers receive accurate appraisals and informed guidance on fine jewelry purchases.
Larry Hirsch
Former Owner
Larry Hirsch managed Westerly Jewelry for decades before passing leadership to Kevin Algiere. He returned from a legal career to preserve the family legacy, emphasizing quality and community ties for over 50 years.
Questions
How do you determine the authenticity of gold or silver items?
Our specialists use professional testing methods to assess purity and authenticity. Bring items to our store for a free evaluation with no obligation to sell.
What services does Westerly Jewelry offer besides sales?
We provide jewelry repairs, watch battery replacements, diamond grading, custom design, and free appraisals for gold, silver, and platinum items.
Are your gemologists certified?
Yes, we employ a Graduate Gemologist certified by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) for expert evaluations and consultations.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Southern Rhode Island, with a focus on Westerly and surrounding communities, offering personalized service to local customers.
How long has Westerly Jewelry been in business?
Since 1934, making us one of Westerly’s longest-standing businesses with three generations of family leadership.
Do you offer financing options?
Financing options may be available for select purchases—contact us directly to inquire about current programs and eligibility.
Reviews (7)
Michael Lussier
May 28, 2022
Report
Very knowledgeable and helpful, works with you to find what satisfies your desires. Easy to talk with and is honest about his products; let's you know the downsides of your selection so you can make the best choice for yourself.
Valerie Brew
Dec 22, 2021
Report
Always 5 star service. I lost a diamond from my ring. Westerly Jewerly, got me a replacement and fixed my ring. It took about a week. But they did a wonderful job.
Ellie Paige
Sep 29, 2021
Report
Stopped in to browse and found a lovely pendant. The have beautiful jewelry and the staff are friendly, attentive and extremely helpful.
Joshua Luzzi
Sep 15, 2021
Report
I can't say enough about how amazing the staff here is! I went there to get a small gold cross to complete my chain and found the perfect one over a year ago. I accidentally got it caught in an old shirt I was wearing and it broke off the arm of Jesus. I was very upset because I could not find the arm and Kevin was able to take a gold wire and repair it just as if it was brand new again. I am so happy! Thank you again!
Frances Bowman
May 05, 2021
Report
Was a customer for years. Last repair done in house was substandard. They were advised about the shoddy work and they absolutely acknowledged that it was very, very poorly done. They were insistent that they be given a chance to fix it, almost to the point of snatching the piece from me. I politely refused stating it should have been done correctly the first time and that I will not be back. I did not ask for a refund because technically it was repaired, just horribly.
What's what more aggravating was that there was never an apology for me having to pay $400 for them to permanently disfigure the item! It appears that quality control is non existant anymore. I will not be using this company for jewelry repairs as it seems their heyday has passed.
What's what more aggravating was that there was never an apology for me having to pay $400 for them to permanently disfigure the item! It appears that quality control is non existant anymore. I will not be using this company for jewelry repairs as it seems their heyday has passed.
Brian
Mar 17, 2021
Report
Great jewelry store in historic downtown Westerly. Employees that have been there for years. They take their time with you. They always help me find exactly what I'm looking for. If they don't have it in the store they will order it. Always receiving what I order within a few days. They follow precious metal prices daily. Always great prices. The jewler is top notch. Great repairs/adjustments. Highly recommended.
Norman Bailey
Jun 18, 2020
Report
Went to Westerly Jewerly to get engraving on a medical alert bracelet. They asked if I had bought it there. No. Then they don't engrave it. Nearest place they know of is at the Crystal Mall in Waterford, CT. Asked another jewlery store and they said go to Negrelli's Jewlery. Who just about happens to be directly across the street from Westerly Jewlery. Nigrelli's is doing the engraving.
