Business Details
We have served the Sun Prairie community with excellence since 1871, making us one of the oldest and most trusted jewelry stores in the region. Our master jewelers, Art and Mike, bring decades of combined experience to every piece we handle, ensuring precision and care in all repairs and custom designs. With Art Fish leading the business since 2020, we continue to uphold our legacy of quality while embracing modern innovations in jewelry craftsmanship. We specialize in restoring heirlooms, resizing rings, and creating one-of-a-kind custom pieces that reflect our clients' unique stories. Our commitment to personalized service means we work closely with customers to understand their vision, ensuring every interaction is pressure-free and focused on their satisfaction. As a family-owned business, we take pride in maintaining transparent practices and building lasting relationships with our clients.
Our on-site repair services guarantee that your jewelry remains in trusted hands from start to finish, with meticulous attention to preserving its value and sentimental significance. We stand behind every piece we sell or repair, offering guarantees that reflect our confidence in our work. By combining traditional techniques with contemporary design, we deliver jewelry that stands the test of time. Our teams expertise in diamond and gemstone selection ensures clients receive only the highest quality materials, ethically sourced and carefully evaluated. We remain dedicated to enhancing the beauty of our customers lives through jewelry that celebrates milestones and cherishes memories.
Our on-site repair services guarantee that your jewelry remains in trusted hands from start to finish, with meticulous attention to preserving its value and sentimental significance. We stand behind every piece we sell or repair, offering guarantees that reflect our confidence in our work. By combining traditional techniques with contemporary design, we deliver jewelry that stands the test of time. Our teams expertise in diamond and gemstone selection ensures clients receive only the highest quality materials, ethically sourced and carefully evaluated. We remain dedicated to enhancing the beauty of our customers lives through jewelry that celebrates milestones and cherishes memories.
Highlights and features
- We offer over 150 years of combined expertise in jewelry craftsmanship and repair.
- Our master jewelers provide guaranteed, on-site services without third-party intermediaries.
- We create fully customized jewelry using client-owned materials or new designs.
- Our engagement ring selection includes conflict-free diamonds and lab-grown options.
- We maintain a pressure-free shopping environment with transparent pricing and processes.
Services
Jewelry Repair
Our master jewelers perform precise repairs for all jewelry types, from simple fixes to complex restorations. We specialize in preserving the integrity of heirlooms and sentimental pieces while ensuring functionality and longevity. Clients benefit from our on-site capabilities, which eliminate the need for third-party shipping and ensure their valuables remain securely in our care.
Ring Resizing
We offer expert ring resizing using advanced techniques that maintain the structural integrity of delicate metals and settings. This service is particularly valuable for engagement rings and heirlooms, ensuring proper fit without compromising craftsmanship. Our jewelers carefully assess each piece to determine the safest and most effective resizing method.
Custom Jewelry
We collaborate with clients to create unique, handcrafted pieces that reflect their personal style and stories. Whether repurposing existing materials or designing from scratch, we guide clients through every stage, from concept to final creation. Our custom process emphasizes individuality, resulting in timeless pieces that carry lasting sentimental value.
Engagement Rings
We curate a diverse collection of engagement rings featuring diamonds, moissanite, and gemstones in classic and modern designs. Clients receive personalized guidance without sales pressure, ensuring they find a ring that aligns with their preferences and budget. Our expertise in diamond grading and setting techniques guarantees exceptional quality and value.
Jewelry Appraisals
We provide detailed jewelry appraisals for insurance, estate planning, or resale purposes, conducted with meticulous attention to detail. Our certified professionals assess each pieces materials, craftsmanship, and market value to deliver accurate, trustworthy documentation. This service helps clients make informed decisions about their jewelrys future.
Reviews (7)
Kyle Nickerson
May 13, 2022
Report
Prairie Jewelers did an awesome job resizing my grandmothers old rings. I would highly recommend this business to anyone looking for a Jeweler near Madison! My grandfather passed a few years back and my grandma was looking to get her rings resized. She was super nervous to have someone work on them because they hold tremendous sentimental value. Once we talked to Art, she felt much more at ease. He went over the ring resizing process and handled us with care. We left the rings for a few days and they were ready within a week. Thank you so much! My grandma is now wearing her ring again everyday without being worried she is going to lose it.
Justin W.
May 08, 2022
Report
Great local service. Art is always able to explain everything well. Service is clearly important here and willing to help out in all ways possible. We've used Prairie Jewelers for our engagement and wedding bands with great results.
Lori Killian
Apr 23, 2022
Report
I had such a great experience working with Art! I wanted to upgrade the diamond in my wedding set and he worked with me to find the perfect stone within my budget. He even took the time to find a marquee stone that was the same ratio (length vs width) as my old stone too. End result was gorgeous and I've received many compliments!
Christopher Murray
Apr 05, 2022
Report
Just popped in to get my watch batteries replaced. Immediately liked these guys. Very pleasant, did it on the spot and were incredibly reasonable. I'm coming back here again!
Donna Breneman
Feb 13, 2022
Report
Larry and I stopped in today to get an estimate on my moms cocktail ring and have a bracelet link repaired. It was a few minutes to get the bracelet safe again on my wrist. Moms ring was sitting in my jewelry case with being a size 4.5 it did not fit me. Mike gave me an estimate to repair a crushed diamond (how did that happen) bevel repairs and sizing to a 7.5. I look forward to having this back next week and smiling down on it for mom.
Since my sister in law had her rings sized here and told me how much she liked coming here.she passed it on to us. The store is very nice and their jewelry is displayed favorably. They have a huge selection to choose from and with Valentines Day less than 3 weeks away you must come in sooner than later. Will I be back.of course.
Since my sister in law had her rings sized here and told me how much she liked coming here.she passed it on to us. The store is very nice and their jewelry is displayed favorably. They have a huge selection to choose from and with Valentines Day less than 3 weeks away you must come in sooner than later. Will I be back.of course.
Thom Hellenbrand
Dec 28, 2021
Report
I purchased a couple timepieces here. Art is friendly, knowledgeable, and enthusiastic about the products he sells and I couldn't be happier with the service I received. More than fair prices. I won't hesitate to recommend Prairie Jewelers!
Susan Miller
Nov 23, 2021
Report
Mike has done great work for me. He repaired my earrings and fixed my watch wristband while I waited. Highly recommend Prairie Jewelers.
