Business Details
35 Years
experience
Trusted Jewelry Appraisals & Estate Sales in Oklahoma City
Established in 1991, Appraise Jewelry Shop has built a legacy of trust and expertise in the jewelry industry. With over 49 years of combined family experience, our founder Scott Gordon brings third-generation knowledge to appraisals, estate jewelry sales, and custom design. We specialize in transparent valuations, ethical sourcing, and connecting clients with the true value of their jewelry. Our services are rooted in a deep understanding of market dynamics, gemology, and historical significance, ensuring clients receive accurate assessments and competitive pricing.Committed to environmental and social responsibility, we work exclusively with recycled gold and conflict-free diamonds while advocating for sustainable practices across the supply chain. Our accreditations from leading gemological institutions and decades of experience handling over $1 million in jewelry transactions annually position us as Oklahoma's trusted authority in jewelry appraisal and sales.
Services
Jewelry Appraisals
Estate Jewelry Sales
Custom Jewelry Design
Consignment Services
Ethical Sourcing Consultation
Details
- Year established: 1991
Highlights and features
- Third-generation Oklahoma jeweler with 49 years of family expertise
- Accredited Senior Appraiser with American Society of Appraisers
- Ethical sourcing from recycled gold and conflict-free diamonds
- Transparent pricing with documented commission structures
- Proven success selling millions in jewelry for estates and individuals
Associations and certifications
- Gemological Institute of America
- Gemmological Association of Great Britain
- American Society of Appraisers
- Accredited Gemologists Association
- National Association of Jewelry Appraisers
- Jewelers of America
What people say
Extremely knowledgeable
Friendly and enjoyable
Best possible price
Honesty and integrity
Exemplary professionalism
Services
Jewelry Appraisals
Professional jewelry appraisals determine accurate values for insurance, estate planning, or liquidation. Our certified appraisers use gemological analysis and market research to provide documented valuations. Clients receive detailed reports with photographic documentation and market comparisons.
Estate Jewelry Sales
Specialized estate jewelry sales services help clients maximize returns from inherited pieces. We offer both quick trade sales and long-term consignment options with transparent commission structures. Our market expertise ensures competitive pricing for vintage and antique jewelry.
Custom Jewelry Design
Custom jewelry design services transform client visions into unique pieces. We specialize in diamond and colored gemstone designs using recycled gold. From concept sketches to finished product, our process ensures quality craftsmanship and personalized attention.
Broker's Price Opinion
This service provides realistic selling price estimates for jewelry based on current market conditions. We analyze comparable sales and market trends to help clients decide between trade liquidation or retail consignment options with documented pricing strategies.
Ethical Sourcing Consultation
Ethical sourcing guidance ensures clients' jewelry investments align with environmental and social values. We verify recycled materials and conflict-free origins while educating clients about sustainable practices in the gem and gold supply chain.
People
Scott Gordon
Owner & Certified Gemologist Appraiser
Third-generation Oklahoma jeweler with 49 years of experience. Graduate Gemologist (GIA 1981), Accredited Senior Appraiser (ASA 1990), and Master Gemologist Appraiser (ASA 1991). Specializes in estate jewelry and ethical sourcing.
Questions
What documents should I bring for a jewelry appraisal?
Bring sales receipts, previous appraisals, and any provenance documentation. Clean jewelry and organized records help expedite the appraisal process.
How do you determine jewelry selling prices?
We analyze market comparables, material value, and current demand. Both wholesale liquidation and retail consignment pricing options are provided with transparent commission structures.
Do you buy jewelry outright?
No, we only broker sales to ensure clients receive optimal prices. We provide market expertise while clients retain ownership until final sale agreements.
What ethical sourcing standards do you follow?
We use recycled gold and verify conflict-free diamonds. Our practices align with industry initiatives promoting environmental responsibility and fair labor practices across the supply chain.
How long does the consignment process take?
Trade liquidation typically takes 1 week, while retail consignment lasts 6-12 months. We provide regular sales updates and handle all insurance during the consignment period.
Reviews (5)
Gloria Quezada
Apr 29, 2022
Report
I utilized Scott for appraising jewelry for an estate. He was knowledgeable and provided incredible detail and expert opinion on the pieces he was appraising. It was an enjoyable experience and he provided some much needed information to move forward. I plan on utilizing his services again in the future and highly recommend him!
Kari Zimmerman
Apr 20, 2022
Report
I took my diamond engagement ring to be appraised by Mr. Gordon for insurance purposes. He was kind and knowledgeable and I appreciated his attention to detail and thoroughness. I would not hesitate to use his services again and recommend him to family and friends.
Katie Richardson
Nov 10, 2021
Report
Scott was amazing and so very helpful. It's very rare to find someone who you can trust to guide you through the process of evaluating your jewelry. He was honest, beyond knowledgeable and offered us sound guidance on our next steps! Thank you Scott for taking great care of our family and jewelry!
Alyssa Haffner
Jul 07, 2021
Report
Mr. Gordon is a true professional, very knowledgeable, and helpful. Highly recommend for your jeweler needs.
Aleata Prince
May 22, 2021
Report
I can't say enough positive things about Mr. Gordon. He provided me with everything my insurance company needed. He was insightful and caring. I never doubted that I could trust him handling my grandmothers precious jewels. Many Thanks!
