J Anthony Jewelers

Business Details

39 Years

experience

Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Neenah, WI

Established in 1987, J Anthony Jewelers has built a legacy of excellence in fine jewelry and customer service. Our journey began when Joe and Amy Ziemba transitioned from industrial and dental technology careers to pursue their passion for jewelry, purchasing Faye's Fine Jewelry in Neenah. Over three decades, we've grown from a downtown shop to a standalone destination, blending traditional craftsmanship with modern design. In 2021, Benjamin Ziemba assumed leadership, continuing our family's commitment to quality while introducing contemporary innovations. We specialize in engagement rings, wedding bands, and custom creations, using ethically sourced diamonds and gemstones.

Our expertise extends to jewelry repair, appraisals, and restoration, performed by skilled artisans using advanced techniques. We prioritize transparency through fixed pricing, eliminating haggling or fluctuating discounts. As lifelong Fox Valley residents, we actively support local initiatives while maintaining global standards of excellence. Our store combines generational knowledge with cutting-edge technology, offering personalized service for every client. We believe jewelry represents life's most meaningful moments, and our team ensures each piece tells its unique story. This philosophy has earned us enduring trust in Neenah and beyond.

Services

Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Custom Jewelry Design Jewelry Appraisals Ring Resizing Jewelry Repairs Watch Repairs Rhodium Plating Corporate Gifts Jewelry Restoration

Details

Year established: 1987

Highlights and features

Family-owned since 1987 with three generations of jewelry expertise
Transparent pricing with no haggling or hidden fees
Custom design services tailored to personal style
Comprehensive repair and restoration services by skilled artisans
Community-focused business supporting local initiatives

Website

Update Listing

Services

Engagement Rings

Our collection features classic and contemporary engagement rings with ethically sourced diamonds. Each piece combines superior craftsmanship with personalized design options. Certified gemologists assist in selecting perfect stones meeting strict quality standards.

Custom Jewelry Design

Transform ideas into wearable art through our custom design process. CAD technology and traditional wax modeling create unique pieces. Clients collaborate directly with designers for one-of-a-kind creations reflecting personal stories.

Jewelry Repairs

Expert repair services restore damaged jewelry using precision techniques. Services include prong replacement, chain soldering, and stone setting. Artisans preserve original integrity while extending piece longevity through meticulous craftsmanship.

Watch Repairs

Authorized service center for major watch brands offering battery replacement, movement repair, and water resistance testing. Certified technicians use manufacturer-approved parts to maintain warranty validity and optimal performance.

Jewelry Appraisals

USPAP-compliant appraisals for insurance, estate, or resale purposes. Detailed reports include high-resolution imaging and market analysis. Certified appraisers evaluate diamonds, gemstones, and precious metals using current industry benchmarks.

People

Benjamin Ziemba

2nd Generation Owner - Designer

Third-generation jeweler with formal gemology training. Oversees design operations and business strategy while maintaining hands-on involvement in custom projects. Brings modern perspective to family legacy established in 1987.

Amy Ziemba

Co-Founder - Goldsmith

Trained dental technician turned master goldsmith. Applies precision craftsmanship to jewelry creation and restoration. Developed signature techniques for intricate metalwork that define the store's distinctive style.

Joseph Ziemba

Co-Founder - Goldsmith, Designer

Marketing graduate who transitioned to jewelry industry leadership. Combined business acumen with artistic vision to establish Neenah's premier jewelry destination. Mentored next generation in both technical and operational aspects.

Questions

What types of jewelry services do you offer?

We provide engagement rings, wedding bands, custom designs, appraisals, repairs, and watch maintenance with certified professionals handling each service.

Can you create custom jewelry pieces?

Yes, our CAD technology and traditional methods allow complete customization. Designers collaborate directly with clients to create unique, personalized jewelry items.

Are your diamonds ethically sourced?

All diamonds come from conflict-free sources following Kimberley Process standards. We provide documentation verifying ethical origin for every diamond sold.

Do you repair heirloom jewelry?

Our artisans specialize in restoring antique and vintage pieces using techniques that preserve original integrity while ensuring structural durability for future generations.

What payment options are available?

We accept major credit cards, personal checks, and offer financing through approved third-party providers for qualified customers.

How long have you operated in Neenah?

Since 1987 when we acquired Faye's Fine Jewelry. We moved to our current location in 1998 and have served the community for over three decades.

Videos

Reviews (5)

Write a Review

Kathy Searl

Jun 21, 2022 Report

This place is amazing! I first came in to have a ring appraised. The work was completed within a few days. Then I decided to have the ring sized. I had a wedding coming up that I wanted to wear it for. They went out of their way to make sure everything was done on time. Everybody is so friendly and helpful! My new favorite jewelers!

Candi Lamb

Apr 20, 2022 Report

I have wanted to have a custom ring made for years. No one would do it for me. I moved to WI in January, and my sister-in-law brought me to J. Anthony Jewelers. They were wonderful! So nice, professional, and honest. They made my custom ring without question. They are true artists there! I definitely recommend them for all your jewelry needs!

C. V.

Apr 20, 2022 Report

I can not say enough GREAT THINGS ABOUT J. ANTHONY JEWELERS! I stopped in as I wanted to find the perfect Gold cross for my daughter who is getting confirmed. I did NOT want to go to a mall jeweler and get Lord knows what, but wanted a real home town trusted Jeweler I knew I could trust. They had a few in store, but not what what this picky proud mama had in mind. So here comes Ben with a huge book of tons of options!

He measured, he turned pages, he checked sizes in the store, had my other daughter send me a picture of her cross for size reference, Ben measured that even! WE FOUND IT! 2 days later I was running back to get them ( I bought 2) PERFECT IS THE WORD! Ben had the chains in store and OH my LORD I AM SO EXCITED TO GIVE THIS TO HER! BEN AND THE STAFF WERE AMAZING! AND I WILL NEVER GO ELSEWHERE! ( I said as I was literally jumping for joy with excitment when I left! really you can ask them:) THANK YOU EVER SO MUCH J. ANTHONY! Blessings, Cheri Van Asten

Baron Schuler

Mar 19, 2022 Report

Brought in a couple of large Topaz crystals to have cufflinks crafted out of them. The J Anthony people were very accommodating in sourcing the necessary Jigs to get the work done and they did create some exceptional looking cufflinks. Was very pleased with their work and the turn around time. Will bring a more challenging item in for them in the near future, gem stones with small diamonds incorporated as well. Look forward to seeing what they can do. Very Happy Customer!

Terry Mazza

Feb 09, 2022 Report

J. Anthony Jewelers repaired my wife's wedding ring to look new again after it was cut off by doctors since there was no other way to remove it. We love the result and recommend their service for your most precious jewelry.